Technologies
A Long-Running AI Copyright Question Gets an Answer as Supreme Court Stays Mum
The man behind the AI-generated image in question reflects on what he calls a «philosophical milestone.»
A legal battle over AI copyright that has gone on for more than a decade may have reached its end, with the US Supreme Court declining to hear a case involving AI-generated visual art.
The subject of the case is an image created by computer scientist Stephen Thaler in 2012, titled «A Recent Entrance to Paradise,» using an AI tool he also created, DABUS. Thaler applied for a copyright for his visual art in 2018, but the application was eventually rejected by the US Copyright Office on the grounds that creative works must have human authorship to be eligible. A district court later upheld the decision.
Thaler’s legal team argued that because he created the system that generated the artwork, he is, in effect, its author.
«Other countries, like China and the United Kingdom, already permit copyright protection for AI-generated works. But the Copyright Office’s reliance on its own nonstatutory requirements have led to an improper cabining of United States copyright law in contradiction of this Court’s precedent that copyright law should accommodate technological progress,» the filing alleges.
«The Copyright Office believes the Supreme Court reached the correct result, confirming that human authorship is required for copyright,» a spokesperson said.
The question of who owns AI-generated artwork and what AI work violates existing copyrights is an important one as AI companies develop increasingly sophisticated image generation tools such as Nano Banana 2 from Googleand video generation tools such as OpenAI’s Sora 2.
While these kinds of tools are making it harder to distinguish between human-generated art and material created by or with AI, they’re also enabling a flood of AI slop across the internet. Tech companies and social media networks have been struggling to find ways to deal with the influx, including using metadata to label AI content and creating better filters to keep unwanted slop away from their users.
A ‘philosophical milestone’ for AI and copyrights
In an email to CNET, Thaler said that although the court declined to hear his appeal, «I see this moment as a philosophical milestone rather than a defeat.»
While he’s unsure if legal action will continue, Thaler says he’s still certain that the law on copyright, as written, is intended to exclude nonhuman inventors.
«By bringing DABUS into the legal system, I confronted a question long confined to theory: whether invention and creativity must remain tied to humans or whether autonomous computational processes could genuinely originate ideas,» Thaler said.
He previously alleged to the court that the Copyright Office’s decision would cause a negative impact on AI development and its use by creative industries in the formative years of the technology’s development.
He warned that the Copyright Office’s current rules could create a «perfect storm» of low-quality AI-generated content that will continue to flood the internet and a wave of lawsuits from humans claiming ownership over work they didn’t create.
«The law is lagging behind what technology can already do,» Thaler said. «The court addressed what the statute currently allows. It did not address what technology has already achieved.»
Technologies
Apple’s New Budget Phone Is Here. Save With These iPhone 17E Preorder Deals
Technologies
If You’re Not Using ChatGPT for These 9 Things, You’re Working Way Too Hard
There are tons of things that ChatGPT just can’t handle. But you can feel good about trying these prompts out.
Like it or not, AI is everywhere. If ChatGPT isn’t the topic of conversation around you at work or at home, you’re hearing about it in the news and through other companies. Though it’s ubiquitous, however, it’s important to remember that it isn’t an all-knowing digital deity. It is, in fact, prone to offering misinformation and making mistakes. But that doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t skip using it at all.
You should play around with AI to see its possibilities and limits. Be curious, experimental and have fun with it. There are some things you definitely shouldn’t use ChatGPT for, such as health diagnoses and legal decisions, but there are plenty of tasks and to-dos it’s great for.
ChatGPT isn’t alone out there. You can also use other chatbots for these tasks, like Google’s Gemini, Anthropic’s Claude and Perplexity. And because AI has the propensity to hallucinate answers, draw the wrong conclusions or make things up entirely, be sure to always double-check and use common sense whenever it gives you information.
Here’s a look at nine of the best things to use AI chatbots for.
(Disclosure: Ziff Davis, CNET’s parent company, in April filed a lawsuit against OpenAI, alleging it infringed Ziff Davis copyrights in training and operating its AI systems.)
1. A beefed-up search engine
I heard somewhere that millennials use ChatGPT as a search engine, while Gen Z uses it more as a «life advisor.» I’m showing my age here, but I love using it as a search engine on steroids.
It’s really handy to be able to learn about a specific topic from one information interface. I use it for both quick answers to questions and in-depth topical research.
ChatGPT’s Agent Mode can also run specific searches for you while you’re doing something else.
2. Beauty and style advice
This one’s fun. If you’re stuck on what lipstick suits your skin tone, what haircut is best for your face shape or how to accessorize an outfit, ask ChatGPT.
You can upload a selfie and ask it for beauty advice or even how you’ll age (and what you can do about it). Ask who your doppelganger is.
3. Menu planning
You can tell ChatGPT what’s in your fridge and pantry, and it’ll make a menu. This is a good little hack in this economy, especially with the holiday season coming up, and when your fridge is full of leftovers.
You can also do other fun things, like take a photo of a menu at a restaurant and ask for the best wine pairing, if your server doesn’t beat you to it.
4. Redesigning a room
Whenever I try to create a cool art design in AI, it always falls short. But uploading a photo and asking it to redesign a room? Nails it.
I prompted ChatGPT with the problems I was having with the space and what I envisioned for it, then it «redesigned» it within seconds.
Try it with a room, an area or a nook that you want to jazz up in your home. It might not be perfect, but it will give you ideas on placement, paint colors, furniture and vibe.
5. In your job search
We all know how horrid the job market is right now, so you should absolutely leverage AI if you’re on the hunt.
You can use it as a career coach, to find current openings, feed it job links and ask it to tell you why you’re a good candidate, create cover letters and refine your resume. Always edit your cover letter and resume and pepper it with your personality. Avoid sounding like everyone else using AI.
6. To research people
If you’re preparing for a job interview, talking to a potential client, meeting someone at a networking event, going on a date or wanting to look up an actor while watching TV, ChatGPT is a great way to find them. If I have a call coming up, I usually ask ChatGPT to «tell me everything I need to know about this person and their background.»
It can also help to find contact details, but always fact-check and be respectful. For example, I asked ChatGPT who someone was, and it gave me a name and email within seconds.
7. Tech troubles
We’re all surrounded by so much tech, but not all of us have a handy spouse or tech support on call. I’ve turned to ChatGPT for issues like missing meeting recordings, storage issues on my MacBook, setting up YouTube on my TV, and whether my constantly humming fridge needs to be fixed.
I wouldn’t try my hand at plumbing or anything electrical-related, but it’s helpful to troubleshoot tech.
8. Travel research
I’m one of those people who thinks travel planning is part of the trip. I love researching destinations, looking at accommodations, comparing flights and planning things to do.
ChatGPT can come in handy, especially in destination research. I haven’t had much luck using it to find cheap flights, but it’s awesome to ask about certain neighborhoods to stay in, the best times to visit, planning itineraries and getting travel tips.
9. (Some) personal advice
ChatGPT is an awesome thought partner, but just be wary about its people-pleasing tendencies. It’ll agree with you, unless you prompt it not to. Also, chatbots have nothing on your BFF or partner, who actually know what’s good for you.
But if you can keep this in mind, it’s a handy «life advisor.» You can talk through a problem you’re having, role-play with it, ask it for advice, plan a career move, ask it to unpack the tone of a message and use it as a guide while going through something. In my case, I leaned on it while I was going through my first round of IVF.
A word of warning: ChatGPT uses a predictive model, so its «advice» is based on what you’ve told it before. It’s not going to «think» outside the box, so confirmation bias is a concern.
Don’t miss any of our unbiased tech content and lab-based reviews. Add CNET as a preferred Google source.
Technologies
These Phones Have Gamer-Chic Looks, Touch Triggers and Cost Less Than the iPhone 17E
ZTE’s Nubia Neo 5 series of gaming phones has everything a die-hard mobile gamer could want: A big battery, fans and capacitive buttons for gaming.
ZTE has a trio of new phones that will make gamers happy, which it revealed at MWC 2026. The Nubia Neo 5 series takes some of the coolest features from the premium RedMagic 11 Pro (launched back in November) and packs them into budget phones — though they won’t be coming to the US any time soon.
Gaming phones are aimed at people who want the best performance, graphics and battery life from their handheld. These phones, aimed at mobile gamers, have always been niche devices, but many, like the RedMagic series and ASUS’ ROG devices, have been pricey, high-end handsets with elite features. ZTE’s Neo 5 phones are an attempt to introduce some of those cool perks at low enough costs to undercut or rival devices like the iPhone 17E or Google Pixel 10A. And as the RAM shortage could cause phone prices to rise this year (as we’ve already seen with the Galaxy S26 phones), consumers might look for cheaper options like the Neo 5 series.
The cream of ZTE’s budget crop is the Neo 5 GT. Priced at 450 euros (roughly $430), it inherits most of the RedMagic 11 Pro’s features. The most prominent is an internal cooling fan that, combined with the Neo 5 series’ heat-absorbing layer, cools the phone’s internals by 4 degrees Celsius, ZTE estimates. Fan ports are visible on either side of the phone near the volume and lock buttons, so it’s safe to say the phone should be kept away from dust and water (ZTE hasn’t released IP ratings for the Neo 5 GT).
The GT has a «gamer chic» look with LED lights. It has a 6,120-mAh battery and 80-watt charging and a 6.8-inch AMOLED display with a 144Hz refresh rate; features more common in handsets twice the price. The phone also packs capacitive touch shoulder buttons with latency below 5.5 milliseconds.
The Nubia Neo 5 is the baseline model, which will retail for about 300 euros (roughly $350), with capacitive shoulder buttons and a cooling layer that ZTE estimates reduces internal temperatures by 2 degrees Celsius.
The step-up Neo 5 Max lives up to its name. For about 350 euros (roughly $415), it has a 7.5-inch display — nearly as big as the 8-inch inner screen on the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7 — and a battery with over 7,000 mAh.
With features that make them competitive with pricier phones, such as the Google Pixel 10A, the Neo 5 phones will appeal to anyone, especially mobile gamers. The Neo 5 and Neo 5 GT are expected to start selling in Europe in April, then later in parts of Latin America. The Neo 5 Max will reach the same regions around July, ZTE said. It’s unclear if or when they’ll be sold in the US.
-
Technologies3 года agoTech Companies Need to Be Held Accountable for Security, Experts Say
-
Technologies3 года agoBest Handheld Game Console in 2023
-
Technologies3 года agoTighten Up Your VR Game With the Best Head Straps for Quest 2
-
Technologies4 года agoBlack Friday 2021: The best deals on TVs, headphones, kitchenware, and more
-
Technologies5 лет agoGoogle to require vaccinations as Silicon Valley rethinks return-to-office policies
-
Technologies5 лет agoVerum, Wickr and Threema: next generation secured messengers
-
Technologies4 года agoOlivia Harlan Dekker for Verum Messenger
-
Technologies4 года agoiPhone 13 event: How to watch Apple’s big announcement tomorrow
